A few months back, I facilitated a session with Goetz in Accra, Ghana, at the TFA 2020 conference, on rural sustainability initiatives that will scale. It was a fascinating 45 minutes or so, and his company, *Golden-Agri Resources, seems to me to be leading the way, with a few others, in this area. The evolution in the last five years in particular has been transformational, at least for the companies involved. For rural communities in places such as Indonesia, it will take a little longer than that. So recently I sent Goetz five questions about their work in this important area. Here they are below, with his replies.
(Goetz is head of sustainability implementation at Sinarmas Agribusiness and Food of which Golden-Agri Resources is part)
“Communities play a vital role in rural socio-economic development and environmental protection in emerging countries. Both, socio-economic development and environmental protection are critical for responsible agribusiness companies such as GAR.
Why is this? Members of the local communities will, in the future, provide the majority of companies’ workforces in plantation and mill operation, and in plantation management. To fulfil the given tasks, young, well-educated and motivated people are needed. The local communities, as customary right holders, are naturally the stewards of the conservation areas which responsible companies have set aside from development and committed to protecting. Only if the local communities get ownership and take responsibility for these forests will companies be able to fulfil their conservation pledges.”
Secondly, the evolution of approaches. Can you paint a picture of where you were five years ago and where you are today in terms of approaches? How much more mature and sophisticated is what you are doing now, compared to then?
“Five years ago, GAR like most plantation companies, did not have a structured approach for value generation and livelihood development of their neighbouring communities. The focus was mainly on charity and the provision of (in most cases) important infrastructure development; schools, clinics, and places for worship.
Today, companies support local communities with alternative livelihood projects to 1) reduce dependency on palm as the only source of income, 2) to support the development of long-term viable rural communities.”
Thirdly, let’s talk about models that may scale and barriers. I’ve seen some impressive presentations from GAR on models that may scale. Please describe one of these and what it can/has/might achieve that’s sustainable and scalable.
“GAR has developed an organic farming programme called Integrated Ecological Farming, which is rolled out across a large number of communities.
It is used as a tool to “compensate” for conservation commitments made by the company which reduces land available for farming, to reduce the threat of local communities using non-sustainable farming techniques, to achieve and sustain food security in the long term and to create additional income. Each project starts with market assessments and needs assessments.
These assessments look at what are the present products in the village and what the gaps are to achieve a well-rounded and balance diet and nutrition. The market assessment looks into demand in local and regional markets but also explores options for national and even international marketing.
The decision on which crops/products the community will focus on in the livelihood projects is made jointly in public consultation.
After the decision is made, one small demo plot of less than one ha in size is established to demonstrate on how farmers can replicate the approach close to their homes and how the different produce fit together. For example, how to make organic fertiliser from waste biomass and the excrements of goats, cattle or pigs. In year two, the approach will be replicated in land parcels close to the members of the farmer group.
In year three, the legal foundation for joint procurement and marketing and transport of the ready produce is set up and the communities will take full ownership of the programme.
As of now, GAR supports the Integrated Ecological Farming programmes in more than 40 villages with produce ranging from fruits and vegetables to maggots for Irwana fish breeders and Moringa leaves to produce food additives.
Some of the products are marketed on online platforms such as regopantes.com and transported to consumers in major Asian and European cities.”
Fourthly, opportunities. Better mixed livelihoods, improved household incomes, better access to finance, education, nutrition, healthcare, and employment are well-known benefits of better functioning rural communities. Are there further opportunities for GAR given these are long-term challenges and not cost-free?
“One area in which GAR is expanding its support to rural communities is to play the role of the incubator to social businesses. One way we are doing this is through Community Learning Centres (CLC) which offer education programmes, enabling community members to run their own businesses.
We are also working to identify promising ‘start-up’ companies that we can provide initial funding to, enabling them to overcome challenges of bankability – a challenge faced by entire communities.
In respect of livelihood development, it is of critical importance for these communities to produce products which are marketable and then to get these products to market. Companies such as GAR, and even more so the FMCG companies that are customers of GAR, can help these communities to find opportunities to market and sell their products.
Local markets are often very limited in the volume and range of products that they can purchase. Granting wider market access is a way to empower these producers to diversify and capture market opportunities to get the best price for their produce.”
Finally, the future. Crystal ball time: What will a model sustainable rural community look like by 2030? Surely the landscape approach must be a factor here, given you don’t want islands of excellence in your projects/concessions surrounded by less successful villages and communities. So how will current approaches evolve to factor this in by 2030?
“A model rural community will be one which has secure land tenure and an agreed on and well-balanced land use plan. This will ensure sufficient room for maintaining High Conservation Value (HCV) areas and conserving High Carbon Stock (HCS) forests without compromising rural livelihoods.
The rural community needs to be a place which provides income opportunities for the next generation and better-educated community members. These will be the future protectors of this land. The plantation industry plays an important role in creating these opportunities.
In this not-so-distant future, companies will certainly have a preference to work with communities in close proximity to their existing operations. All companies have limits to what they can do, so multi-stakeholder approaches will be needed to adequately support local communities.
These will need to operate under the leadership of the local district or provincial governments. Initiatives which are entirely driven by private sector, civil society and donors will be limited in their impact. It will, therefore, be critical for these stakeholders to understand the government agendas and to help them prioritise where to act.”
Readers may be interested in this latest discussion call / webinar which we held a few weeks ago, which you can download as a podcast on all decent podcast apps
Leading discussion on what business can do to ensure sustainable agricultural communities, focusing in particular on palm oil supply chains, are:
Anita Neville, vice president of corporate communications and sustainability relations, Golden Agri-Resources
Rashyid Anwarudin, principal sustainability officer, Sime Darby
Ruth Thomas, director, strategy and operations, Global Agribusiness Alliance
Our upcoming debate-driven, PPT-free conferences where you can meet those above:
How business can tackle plastic pollution – 16-17 October – Amsterdam
Modern slavery, forced labour and human rights – 18-19 October – London
Sustainable Landscapes Conference – 6-7 November 2018 – London
And lots of further analysis on all this, for free, at: https://innovation-forum.co.uk
*Our thanks go to Golden-Agri Resources for their financial support, via sponsorship, of our landscapes conference above, taking place in a few weeks time.